"What Is It???" Wednesday

One of the fringe benefits of spending time in the City of St. Augustine's Archaeology lab is getting to ogle some really fascinating artifacts from time to time.  When I visited the lab last Friday Carl showed me this little gem, found while excavating across the street from the Castillo de San Marcos:

Stumped?  Here it is from the side...

And the front...

And one more angle...

SO WHAT IS IT???

Leave your best guess in the comments section below!


By the way, the answer to last week's WIIW post is the Windover Site in Brevard County.  Congratulations to our winner, Alex Buell! 

To find out more about Windover, click here.  For much more detail, check out the book!